An intermission before the actual post. I have been keeping up with the crazy home birth vs. hospital debates [see below for links] and there's been a lot of mean things said. By everyone. One comment maligned home birth moms for wanting a 'perfect birth', an unattainable ideal that is just 'silly'. Well, I think we all want a 'perfect birth' and I think we should all hope for that. Reality is that sometimes it won't be perfect, but isn't life all about hoping and striving for those perfections?
Anyway, everyone has an opinion, everyone has emotional ties, and everyone interprets the statistics differently. I don't really care. This is my blog and this about what I want. :)
- I want to have a VBAC.
- I want to deliver with VBAC-friendly medical staff.
- I want a doula
- I want as few interventions as possible.
The reason I wouldn't want a lot of pain medication and 'intervention' is because your likelihood of having a repeat Cesarean goes up as you get induced, epidurals, etc. An example: Early Epidural Double C-Section Risk After Induction.
Plus, with DS, I had some sort of narcotic drug to help with the pain and it only made me dizzy and nauseous. That's not what I had in mind.
- I want to eat my placenta.
As a Certified Nurse Midwive I talked to recently told me, there's not enough evidence one way or the other on this one. People think it might help 'replenish' the mom's energy and stave off depression, but there's no proof that it does. Here's a link to one mom who ate her placenta (it still sounds gross) but wishes she hadn't: I Regret Eating My Placenta. Anyway, that's why I say I'd do it on the off chance. :)
- I want to feel empowered.
Current Crazy Debate (In Order of Publication):
Home Birth: Increasingly Popular, But Dangerous by Michelle Goldberg
How To Scare Women by Jennifer Block
Michelle Goldberg Answers A Critic's Distortions of Her Home-birth Argument by Michelle Goldberg
Separating Evidence From Ideaology in the Homebirth Debate by Jennifer Block
A blog post about this debate: Smart Women Debate Homebirth
The Skeptical OB's (Dr. Amy Tuteur) Take:
Jennifer Block: Whack-A-Mole Journalist
Navel-Gazing Midwife Takes On Jennifer Block
First, let me say, you are hilarious Nicky. I love reading your blog. Second, I've had all three of my children at home and I don't buy the b.s. that homebirths are MORE dangerous than hospital births. Each have their risks; it's up for a mom and dad to decide exactly what the cost/benefit is for each situation. And each has a 'model of care', so go with the one that better fits your goals and comfort level. We're creatures of instinct; wherever we feel most comfortable is where we will do our best birthing.
ReplyDeleteHave you been reading these debates? I'm surprised at how polarized it is; I don't think it's good to be radically against either home birth or hospital birth. I think that dependent on the situation, the circumstances, and the parents a home birth, a hospital, or a birth center would do just fine. I think when things go wrong it's often the result of so many variables that it's hard to point to any one thing that would have made the difference. It depends on your care givers, your body, this, that, and the other thing. Sigh.
ReplyDelete